HomeJudge ProgramThe Team Lead Certification

The Team Lead Certification

This is a living article that we’ll update from time to time in order to talk about the current state and process for the TLC. The last update was in November 2026.

The following applies starting in 2027. Any checklist handed in before the end of the year will be following the old check list process that you can find here: [LINK]

This article describes the Team Lead Certification (TLC): what it encompasses, for whom it is for and who, to achieve it.

The Team Lead Certification (TLC) is a certification awarded to Level 2 Flesh and Blood Judges who have demonstrated the necessary skills and competence for leading a team of judges at large-scale Flesh and Blood events. Team leads are critical to the fabric of a main event: they ensure that the specific group of tasks assigned by the event’s head judge to the various teams are executed successfully by team members. Team leads excel at process execution, task coordination, communication, and providing guidance to other judges at the events, all of which contribute to the overall success of a large judge staff for Flesh and Blood main events. 

When someone has completed their TLC, tournament organizers and others responsible for event staffing know that the TLC holder has been vetted to a higher-standard and is capable of leading a team of judges for Flesh and Blood main events. The certification does not guarantee that a judge is staffed into a Team Lead or Judge Lead position at any particular event (as team lead opportunities may be limited); however, holding the certification makes it easier for organizers to identify individuals with the skills necessary to team lead in order to consider them for available team lead opportunities.

Currently, holding a TLC is required to be a team lead at a Pro Tour or World Championship main event. We expect to expand this requirement during 2027 – this article will be updated with plenty of lead time when it does.

Process Overview

The TLC requires a mix of in-person event requirements as well as non-event requirements. Details on the exact requirements are listed in the next section.

  1. Checklist submission – Fill out your checklist on Judgehub (you need to be logged in)
  2. Checklist approval or rejection
    • If approved, the process continues to step 3.
    • If rejected, the candidate can resubmit a new checklist with revised requirements tailored to the checklist’s weak points and with additional requirements. This comes with a cooldown period. Failing the checklist twice will result in a 6-month cooldown period – adjustments may vary depending on the candidate.
  3. Online Workshop with other candidates before the evaluation. This workshop is part of our new online conferences schedule and will be held 3 to 4 times per year and will take around two hours.
  4. Evaluation at a Calling weekend, either at the Calling itself or at selected Showdowns.
    • If a pass, the TLC role will be given
    • If a non-pass, adjusted requirements, similar to 2.b. will be provided

We expect all written work and thinking during this process to originate from the candidate themselves, rather than from others or from AI tools. To reiterate, other individuals and AI tools should NOT be used to generate any part of a submission, including written work, feedback reviews, self-reviews, or statements submitted as part of the checklist. One of the core purposes of a TLC examination is to understand your ability to think critically about the people and actions in front of you. Outsourcing this thinking to others or AI tools reduces our ability to accurately assess your readiness. If you have any questions about this policy, please contact the TLC Project Lead before beginning an item, so that expectations are clear from the outset.

Art by Hoàng Lập

Qualifications

A candidate must meet all of the following criteria:

  • Must have certified for Level 2 at least 180 days prior to application. You must also have been in good standing within the Flesh and Blood Judge Program for that same period
  • Provide a written statement of 500 words or less demonstrating understanding of leadership or management skills in an event-team setting.;
  • Written feedback and/or a review of other judges in the Flesh and Blood Judge Program. This feedback must be aimed to help the receiving judge. These should be standard “evaluation” reviews giving voluntary feedback based on observations at an event, not reviews that are required to be submitted as part of any advancement or certification process.
  • Write a self review in 500 or fewer words  describing your strong and weak points based on the TLC qualities listed below. 
  • Worked at least two World Championship, Pro Tour, Calling or Showdown (for Showdowns at Tier 4 and World Premiere weekends only) tournaments. These events must have occurred within 24 months prior to the date of the candidate’s application submission.
  • Provide a history of having worked at teams that have performed the following tasks. Teams can also have the tasks below combined.
    • Deck Checks
    • End of Round
    • Features
    • Floor
  • Have an endorsement from a member of the Calling Head and Support Judge group. This endorsement is not a full review and is rather just the approval

Please, be extra diligent when submitting your application; a declined checklist results in delays in your TLC process.

Qualities of a Team Leader

  • Preparation and Task Execution
    • A successful candidate will be someone who
      • Understands what the goal of all teams on an event are
      • Can successfully create and communicate to their team a plan to complete the team’s assigned goal
      • Can adapt that plan to the realities of the event
  • Leadership
    • A successful candidate will be someone who
      • Creates a strong team environment
      • Handles the decision-making stress of an ongoing event well
      • Makes their team feel engaged and involved in the success of the event
  • Communication
    • A successful candidate will be someone who
      • Has timely communication with all relevant contact points in the event
      • Delivers all pre-event communication on schedule
      • Clearly explains team tasks to their team
      • Knows when to ask for more information
      • Knows when to escalate issues to Head Judges and/or the TO
  • Policy, Procedures, Penalties, and Rules
    • A successful candidate will be someone who
      • Understand how to correctly apply procedures at Competitive and Professional REL
      • Be confident in the rules where other judges will feel comfortable coming to them for assistance
      • Understand when to propose a deviation from the rules to a Head Judge
  • Feedback, Mentoring, and Personal Development
    • A successful candidate will be someone who
      • Knows how to give both positive and corrective feedback to other judges, including judges perceived to be more senior within the program
      • Can identify their own strengths and weaknesses and come up with plans to mitigate those weaknesses while they improve
      • Uses time during the event to improve other judges

Coordinating Your Evaluation

After submitting your checklist and receiving approval from the TLC Project Lead (TLCPL) , the candidate will work with the TLCPL on scheduling the next available evaluation opportunity.

Below are the steps both the candidate and TLCPL will work towards in coordinating an appropriate date for evaluation:

  1. The candidate will contact the TLCPL with a date and event they are staffed for where they would like to be evaluated.
    • The candidate must inform the TLCPL of their desire to be evaluated at least (8) weeks prior to the event’s start date.
    • Given the limited number of spots available per event, there may be instances where the candidate is unable to be evaluated at the time. 
  2. The TLCPL will work with the event’s Tournament Organizer, Head Judge and Team Lead Evaluators (TLE) on putting the candidate in a team lead position in order to be evaluated and observed by a TLE.
  3. The TLCPL will notify the candidate if they are able to be evaluated at their desired event.
    • If the candidate can be evaluated at their desired event, the TLCPL will provide the candidate with the information of the TLE who will be observing them, as well as the team the candidate will be leading during their evaluation. 
    • If the candidate cannot be evaluated at their desired event, the candidate will work with the TLCPL to identify the next potential event where they wish to be evaluated (see step 1).

Evaluation

After receiving confirmation from the Team Lead Certification Project Lead (TLCPL) of the event, the candidate will be in charge of executing all responsibilities and tasks required of the team lead position they have been assigned. As part of the TLCPL’s coordination activity, a Team Lead Evaluator (TLE) will be assigned to the candidate to conduct the evaluation process.

To conduct their evaluations, Team Lead Evaluators (TLE) will be observing the candidate during their time in the team lead role, looking for their performance in the following set of evaluation criteria. During the evaluation, TLEs will evaluate while being a standard team member.

Team Lead Evaluators (TLE)

Team Lead Evaluators (TLE) are individuals who have the responsibility of evaluating candidates seeking their Team Lead Certification (TLC). In general, TLEs are a qualified group of individuals composed of Premier Events Head Judges / Support Judges and subject-matter experts with the trusted responsibility of performing these evaluations. 

Assigned TLEs will be positioned on the candidate’s team on the event day and will work the event as normal (e.g. execute assigned tasks) while observing the candidate in their team lead role. The TLE is not an advisor to the team lead in this position and will not intervene in the candidate’s team lead responsibilities.

To facilitate the process, the candidate must include the TLE in all event-related communications (e.g. pre-event planning, head judge, intra-team and cross-team communications). This is to ensure that the TLE has as much exposure as possible to the activities the candidate is performing while in their team lead position. While the evaluation is ongoing, the TLE may reach out to other members of the event’s judge staff for additional insight necessary to complete the evaluation. 

To become a Team Lead Evaluator, judges must meet one of the following requirements:

  1. Any judge with the Premier Event HJ or SJ certification
  2. Any judge holding the TLC and meeting the following criteria can request an interview to become TLE
  3. Experience leading the following teams: End of Round, Deck Checks, Features, and Floor at least once.  Experience leading teams of 2+ members eight(8) times. Experience Head Judging (not Support Judging) an event with 5+ judges, twice. 

Once a judge meets the above criteria, they must pass an interview with two of the following persons to become a TLE: Judge Manager, Judge Community Manager, Advanced Certification Lead, or TLCPL. To schedule that interview, please email the TLCPL. Include evidence of your experience listed above.

Evaluation End

After the event concludes, a short reflection period will be provided to the Team Lead Evaluators (TLE) to complete the evaluation process on their side. This is to allow the TLE to gather additional information as necessary, such as input from the event’s Head Judge and other team leads on the candidate’s conduct, performance and interactions with them. 

After the TLE submits their evaluation, a decision will be rendered for the candidate. Candidates who successfully demonstrate and pass the evaluation step will receive the Team Lead Certification (TLC). Candidates who do not pass their evaluation will receive feedback on development opportunities that they can work towards for future evaluations.

If a candidate fails the TLC, they may reattempt after meeting the additional requirements. To reattempt the TLC, the candidate must:

  1. Work a Tier 3+ event as a floor judge in a World Championship, Pro Tour, Calling or Showdown (Showdown at Tier 4 and World Premiere weekends only) tournament.
  2. Write a review on their Team Leader during an event post-evaluation.
  3. Any additional task the TLCPL may state to help the candidate improve in the deficiencies shown during the evaluation.

If a candidate fails the TLC two times, they can no longer test for TLC without the explicit approval of the Judge Manager. We recommend giving this process the time and energy it needs rather than trying to force it. Use the chance to talk to judges who have done the evaluation.

Questions & Outlook

For any questions about the Team Lead Certification process, please reach out to the Team Lead Certification Project Lead.

This is the revised process starting with checklists that are submitted in 2027 and later. Any checklist handed in before the end of 2026 will follow the old process – check out the old article here! If you are currently trying to submit a new checklist after a previous rejection, you can still do so going forward or you create a checklist in the new system.

Author

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest Articles